“The Cost of Diesel Topped $6.50 per Gallon.”
Fuel prices are trucking’s top concern in ATRI’s 22nd annual Top Industry Issues report, released October 18 from a survey of nearly 3,100 industry stakeholders. Driver issues are back in the top 10 behind it: the driver shortage returned at No. 5 and driver retention at No. 10, and driver compensation held at No. 9. Motor carriers put lawsuit abuse reform in their own top 3. The economy, No. 1 for the previous 3 years, fell to No. 6.
Read from the carrier’s seat, the list comes down to 2 assets: the truck and the driver. Fuel and the driver issues are the cost of running those 2 assets, and lawsuits and insurance are the cost of putting them on the road. In trucking, if you ain’t turning, you ain’t earning, and each issue near the top of ATRI’s list costs money to keep a truck and its driver turning.
Shippers and brokers pay for the same list. They pay for fuel through the surcharge and for litigation through rates, because a broker’s lawsuit and the repricing that follows flow down to the shipper.
What ATRI’s 2026 List Ranked
More than 48% of ATRI’s respondents were motor carrier executives and personnel, 26% were truck drivers, and 26% were other freight stakeholders. Drivers, both owner-operators and company drivers, ranked fuel prices, truck parking, and driver compensation as their top 3 concerns. Motor carriers named lawsuit abuse reform, fuel prices, and the driver shortage as theirs.
The full list also includes CSA and insurance cost/availability, and 2 issues that debuted on ATRI’s 2025 list held their top-10 spots: artificial intelligence in trucking and diesel emissions regulations. ATRI reads the economy’s fall to No. 6 as cautious optimism among motor carriers.
Fuel: The Cost That Barely Moved in 2025
In 2025, fuel was one of only 2 cost lines in ATRI’s 2026 Analysis of the Operational Costs of Trucking that rose more slowly than inflation. The total cost to operate a truck still reached a record $2.336 a mile, and truckload and refrigerated operating margins stayed below 1%.
Then diesel climbed. Ben Banks, president of TCW, put it this way in ATRI’s release: “Just as we started to see some positive signs in the freight economy, the cost of diesel topped $6.50 per gallon.” He said the spike “is particularly painful for small- to mid-size fleets.” The Energy Information Administration’s price for the week of October 19 put on-highway diesel at $6.276 a gallon, $2.656 higher than a year earlier.
Nobody buys diesel below the market. What a fleet controls is how many gallons each truck buys, which states it buys them in, how far off route it goes to get them, and whether the driver follows the plan. EIA’s October 19 prices ran from $5.740 a gallon in the Lower Atlantic states to $8.242 in California, and part of that $2.502 gap is state fuel tax, which IFTA settles each quarter by the miles a truck ran in each state. Comparing 2 stations means comparing them after tax, and that comparison, made at every stop on the route, is how carriers that outperform on record diesel hold down their fuel spend. Shippers pay the same diesel prices through the surcharge, and checking each surcharge against the carrier agreement table is where that cost gets caught.
Drivers: Retention Is Decided in the Dispatch Plan
For a driver paid by the mile, every hour the truck sits is an hour without mileage pay. ATRI’s cost study found that driver pay rose more slowly than inflation in 2025 for the second year in a row and that deadhead mileage remained elevated. Carriers also left 10% of their trucks unseated on average. An unseated truck earns nothing, and neither does a driver running empty or waiting at a dock.
Say dispatch has 20 loads and 15 trucks. The 5 extra loads go to a broker or another carrier, and each of the 15 matches sets how far a driver runs empty to reach the next pickup. The same match decides whether that driver gets home when dispatch said. Driver retention ranks No. 10 on ATRI’s list, and those matches decide it. Drivers welcome technology that keeps them loaded on freight they want to haul, and they push back on technology that micromanages them.
Truck parking made the drivers’ own top 3. For the driver, the fuel stop and the place to take a required break and park are one decision, and the plan should treat them as one.
The plan is only half the job. Once a load is dispatched on its route, the forecast has to keep up. Most visibility tools forecast the delivery and stop there. We forecast both pickup and delivery and recalculate them from the route, the truck’s position, and dock events as the load moves, because most delays start on the run to pickup or at the dock. A late pickup also costs the driver hours they needed for the rest of the trip, and sometimes their home time at the end. What actually happened at that dock then goes into the plan for the next load there.
Trucks Crashed Less, and Claims Cost a Third More
Heavy-duty truck-involved crash rates fell 2.6% from 2021 to 2024, and per-mile liability losses at the fleets in ATRI’s May 2026 insurance research rose an average of 33.1% over the same years. Coming from insurance and risk, I read those 2 numbers the way an underwriter does, as a litigation problem. Premiums followed losses, rising 18.6% to 10.2 cents a mile, 5.4 percentage points faster than consumer inflation.
The excess layers rose fastest. Premiums for the $5 million to $10 million layer rose 34% to 1.58 cents a mile, and the $10 million to $15 million layer rose 45% to 1.05 cents, increases ATRI says “point to the role of rampant litigation in inflating claims costs.” Litigation cost is what puts lawsuit abuse reform in the carriers’ own top 3.
For a broker, the exposure changed on May 14. That day, the Supreme Court ruled 9-0 in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II that a broker can be sued under state law for negligently selecting a carrier, putting the record of how it chose each carrier before a jury.
For Carriers: Keep the Truck Loaded and the Driver Turning
Lawsuit abuse reform, fuel prices, and the driver shortage were the carriers’ own top 3, and all of them land on the truck and the driver.
Put Home Time Into Every Load Match
When dispatch matches loads to drivers, weigh each driver’s location, hours of service, home time, and the cost of getting from the delivery to the next pickup in the same decision. Driver retention is back in ATRI’s top 10, and a driver’s promised home time is kept or broken one match at a time.
Cost is the hours-of-service and home-time data already in your dispatch and ELD records.
Measure Every Hour Your Drivers Wait at a Dock
Record arrivals and departures at every facility in telematics, bill detention when free time runs out, and pay the driver’s detention from the same record. A driver paid by the mile earns nothing while the truck waits, and the customer can verify the detention charge that gets paid.
Cost is the telematics timestamps your trucks already send.
Plan Fuel Stops Around Hours of Service and Parking
Choose each fuel stop where the driver can also take a required break and find a place to park. A cheaper station costs more if the detour burns clock time or leaves the driver hunting for a space, and truck parking made the drivers’ top 3.
Cost is the hours-of-service and stop data you already have.
Bring Your Safety Record to the Renewal
Before your next renewal, document the safety technologies on your trucks and your loss history, and ask your insurance agent to price a higher retention in the primary layer alongside your current program. ATRI data show that fleets that kept more risk in the primary layer had lower combined liability losses and premiums at every fleet size, and that deploying 6 safety technologies correlated with lower per-mile liability losses. Those 2 findings give an underwriter something to price besides the last verdict in the news.
Cost is your loss runs and a list of the safety technology on each truck, both of which you already have.
Where EKA Fits
EKA Omni-TMS runs carriers, brokers, and shippers on one record, and EKA’s AI agents orchestrate the routine work behind the issues at the top of ATRI’s list, from the plan through execution, with the exceptions routed to your team.
Follow one load through EKA. EKA ALO AI, the asset load optimizer for fleets, picks the truck and driver for it, weighing location, hours of service, equipment, timing, and the driver’s home time, and dispatch confirms the match. EKA Route AI plans the run around the driver’s hours and the receiver’s appointment, and EKA EconFuel AI tells the driver where along that route to buy fuel and how many gallons; EKA’s EconFuel AI page puts the result at 3% to 8% off fuel spend within a few months. At the dock, EKA DockTime AI starts the clock against the facility’s free time, and if the free time runs out, that same timestamp triggers the detention invoice and the driver’s detention pay.
From the moment the load is dispatched, EKA On-Time AI forecasts every pickup and delivery, tracking the predicted time through the run to pickup, the dwell at the dock, the line haul, and final delivery. On-Time AI recalculates as the load moves, measures each load against the delay threshold set for that shipper and that load, and alerts your team and the shipper while there is still time to act. Visibility and service management by shipper and by load is what the customer sees in the plan.
If a shipper’s dock keeps holding trucks past their appointments, the next plan for that dock should expect it. WAMS, the workflow activity monitoring system under every agent, records each task and event on every load as it happens, and DockTime AI reports detention by shipper, facility, lane, and driver. The next load to that dock gets planned based on how the last ones there actually ran, and the platform keeps learning load by load.
On the risk side, EKA’s risk and compliance guardrails check carrier authority, insurance, and safety at tender and booking, block non-compliant carriers before booking, and keep an audit-ready record of every check. ALO AI applies the same idea to a carrier’s own fleet: it matches loads only against drivers and assets that pass the fleet’s compliance checks today.
EKA Control Center AI is the orchestration hub. It gathers the exceptions from every agent into one ranked view and attaches the workflow to resolve each one, so your people spend their time on the loads that need judgment.
EKA is headless and API-first. From the end of Q4 2026, EconFuel AI fuel plans and Route AI routes arrive through the API in the system a fleet already runs, and EKA’s other agents follow in Q1 2027, as laid out on our Services page.
Every issue at the top of ATRI’s list shows up on a truck or a driver. A carrier that plans both together, and keeps both turning, earns the margin to handle the rest.
Diesel will have moved by the time you read this; the prices above are EIA’s for the week of October 19, 2026. The ATRI figures come from the 3 releases linked above. Nothing here is legal, financial, or investment advice.



